Wayfair reported what it called its strongest quarter of sales growth since the pandemic, and the numbers give the company a reason to celebrate. U.S. revenue reached about $3 billion, an 11.4% increase from the year before, and total revenue grew 9.7% to $3.42 billion. Net income of $62 million, or 45 cents per share, compared with a loss of $99 million, or 76 cents per share, a year earlier. Its stock closed about 11% higher on Wednesday. Those are strong results for a retailer in a sluggish market.

The more interesting question is where that growth is coming from. Wayfair says it is taking market share while the overall U.S. category is roughly flat, according to CFO Kate Gulliver. If that is accurate, the company is winning customers from competitors rather than riding a rising tide. Active customers grew 4.7% to 22.2 million, and orders delivered rose 12.2% to about 11 million. Those figures suggest real demand, not just a one-time bump.

Still, the report also shows a weak spot. International net revenue fell 2.3% year over year to $380 million. A company that frames its story around momentum should be able to explain why its results outside the United States are moving in the opposite direction. The report does not offer that explanation, and investors should ask for it.

Gulliver also said the company will keep promotional activity at roughly last year's level into the holiday season. She described heavy promotion as a multi-year pattern, and she pointed to a value-focused price range and a luxury business as reasons customers keep spending. Promotions can drive volume, but they can also erode margins if they must keep running to sustain sales. The company's profit improvement is encouraging, yet a business that depends on constant discounts has to prove it can grow profitably without them.

My view is that Wayfair deserves credit for a strong quarter and for turning a loss into a profit. The next step is to show that the gains are durable, that international operations can stabilize, and that promotional spending is producing lasting customer loyalty rather than temporary traffic. Shareholders and small business owners watching the furniture sector should keep those tests in view.